Markets

Understanding U.S. Trucking Markets

Success in truck dispatching requires deep knowledge of regional freight markets. Rates, demand, and challenges vary dramatically across the United States. A lane that's profitable in one direction might lose money in reverse. Understanding these market dynamics is essential for maximizing revenue and keeping trucks moving efficiently.

---

Why Regional Markets Matter

For Dispatchers:

• Rate Optimization - Know which markets pay premium rates
• Route Planning - Avoid dead zones and expensive backhauls
• Seasonal Strategy - Capitalize on peak demand periods
• Problem Avoidance - Navigate challenging regions effectively

Key Market Factors:

• Supply vs. Demand - More trucks than freight = lower rates
• Geographic Features - Mountains, weather, border crossings
• Economic Activity - Manufacturing hubs, ports, distribution centers
• Seasonal Variations - Harvest, holidays, weather impacts

---

Regional Market Breakdown

🌊 West Coast (CA, OR, WA)

Major Markets: Los Angeles, Oakland/SF Bay Area, Portland, Seattle

Characteristics:

Strengths:

• ✅ Massive import gateway - Ports of LA/Long Beach (40% of U.S. imports)
• ✅ Strong outbound freight - Agricultural products, manufactured goods
• ✅ High population - Retail distribution demand
• ✅ Premium rates outbound - CA → TX, CA → IL, CA → Southeast
• ✅ Technology & agriculture - Diverse freight types

Challenges:

• ❌ Expensive to operate - Fuel, parking, tolls, regulations
• ❌ Congestion - LA/SF traffic delays cost time and money
• ❌ CARB regulations - Strict emissions requirements for trucks
• ❌ High cost of living - Expensive for drivers to layover

Rate Dynamics:

Strong Outbound Lanes (Head Haul):

• CA → TX: $2.50–$3.50/mile (produce, retail goods)
• CA → IL: $2.00–$3.00/mile (import freight to Midwest)
• CA → Southeast: $2.20–$3.20/mile (retail distribution)

Weak Inbound Lanes (Backhaul):

• TX → CA: $1.50–$2.20/mile (returning empty often)
• Midwest → CA: $1.60–$2.30/mile
• Southeast → CA: $1.70–$2.40/mile

Why the Imbalance? More freight leaves California than enters it. California produces massive amounts of agricultural products and receives imports through ports, but doesn't consume as much as it produces/ships.

Dispatcher Strategy:

Best Practices:

• ✅ Maximize outbound rates - Negotiate hard when leaving CA
• ✅ Accept reasonable backhaul - Better to return at $1.80/mile than deadhead
• ✅ Time port pickups carefully - Avoid peak congestion hours
• ✅ Know CARB compliance - Ensure trucks meet emissions standards
• ✅ Build port relationships - Consistent drayage can be lucrative

Peak Seasons:

• Q4 (Oct-Dec): Holiday import surge - highest rates
• Spring/Summer: Agricultural products (berries, lettuce, grapes)
• Year-Round: Consistent import/export activity

Common Freight:

• Imports from Asia (electronics, furniture, clothing)
• Agricultural products (almonds, wine, produce)
• Technology products from Silicon Valley
• Entertainment/film industry equipment

---

🗽 East Coast (NY, NJ, PA, MD, VA, NC, SC, GA, FL)

Major Markets: New York/Newark, Philadelphia, Baltimore, Charlotte, Atlanta, Miami

Characteristics:

Strengths:

• ✅ Dense population corridor - I-95 from Boston to Miami
• ✅ Major import ports - NY/NJ, Savannah, Charleston
• ✅ Manufacturing - Automotive (SC, GA), pharmaceuticals (NJ)
• ✅ Distribution hubs - Atlanta, Charlotte for Southeast distribution
• ✅ Consistent freight - Year-round demand

Challenges:

• ❌ Traffic congestion - I-95, NYC area, DC beltway
• ❌ Tolls - Expensive (NJ Turnpike, Delaware tolls, NYC bridges)
• ❌ Weather - Winter snow/ice (north), hurricanes (south)
• ❌ Parking shortages - Limited truck parking in metro areas

Rate Dynamics:

Strong Lanes:

• NY/NJ → Southeast: $1.80–$2.80/mile
• Southeast → Northeast: $1.90–$2.90/mile (balanced trade)
• Atlanta → Midwest: $1.70–$2.50/mile

Moderate Lanes:

• NY/NJ → Midwest: $1.60–$2.40/mile
• Southeast → Texas: $1.50–$2.30/mile

Dispatcher Strategy:

Best Practices:

• ✅ Avoid NYC unless premium rate - Congestion and cost rarely justify it
• ✅ Use Atlanta as hub - Major crossroads for Southeast
• ✅ Factor toll costs - Add $100–$200 to I-95 corridor runs
• ✅ Plan around weather - Winter storms disrupt Northeast
• ✅ Leverage port freight - NY/NJ, Savannah imports

Peak Seasons:

• Q4: Holiday retail distribution
• Spring: Construction materials to Northeast
• Summer: Beach resorts need supplies

Common Freight:

• Import containers (NY/NJ, Savannah ports)
• Retail distribution to population centers
• Automotive parts (BMW SC, Mercedes AL, Volvo SC)
• Food & beverage (major population centers)
• Pharmaceuticals (New Jersey corridor)

---

🏔️ Mountain Region (AZ, NM, CO, UT, WY, MT, ID)

Major Markets: Phoenix, Denver, Salt Lake City (limited compared to coasts)

Characteristics:

Challenges - The "Dead Zone":

• ❌ Low freight density - Sparse population = less freight
• ❌ Long distances - Miles between cities
• ❌ Mountain passes - I-70 (CO), I-80 (WY), I-90 (MT) elevation changes
• ❌ Weather hazards - Snow, ice, closures (especially Nov-Mar)
• ❌ Fuel costs - Higher prices, lower MPG climbing grades
• ❌ Chain laws - Tire chains required in winter
• ❌ Limited services - Fewer truck stops, repair shops

Strengths:

• ✅ Through-freight corridor - I-80, I-70, I-90 connect coasts
• ✅ Some strong markets - Denver (distribution), Phoenix (winter produce)
• ✅ Mining & energy - Wyoming, Montana, New Mexico
• ✅ Lower competition - Many drivers avoid these areas

Rate Dynamics:

Reality Check: Most freight through this region is transit freight (passing through), not destination freight.

Problem Lanes:

• CA → Denver: Decent outbound ($2.00–$2.80/mile) but difficult to get out
• Denver → CA: Backhaul rates ($1.40–$2.00/mile) - often deadhead
• AZ → UT/WY: Low demand, low rates ($1.20–$1.80/mile)
• MT/ID → anywhere: Very limited freight options

Better Approach:

• CA → TX: Route through I-10 (southern) to avoid mountain region
• CA → Midwest: Route through I-80 north or I-40 south to skip empty zones
• Northeast → CA: Use I-70 only if paid well for transit

Dispatcher Strategy:

Best Practices:

• ⚠️ Avoid booking into mountain region unless load pays exceptionally well
• ⚠️ Don't leave driver stranded in Denver, Salt Lake, Albuquerque without next load
• ✅ Plan coast-to-coast routes that minimize mountain time
• ✅ Use I-10 (southern route) when possible - flatter, warmer, more freight
• ✅ Charge premium for winter mountain freight (if you must)
• ✅ Denver as quick stop only - In and out same day if possible

Winter Survival:

• Only experienced drivers in winter months
• Always check weather before dispatching
• Have backup plans for pass closures
• Factor extra time for chain-up requirements
• Never send reefer through mountains in deep winter (fuel costs skyrocket)

Common Freight (Limited):

• Mining equipment (WY, NM, MT)
• Oil & gas supplies (CO, WY)
• Agricultural products (ID potatoes, CO produce)
• Construction materials to Denver metro
• Winter produce from Arizona

The Bottom Line: The mountain region is a necessary evil when traveling coast-to-coast. Experienced dispatchers minimize time spent here and avoid booking loads that end in these markets unless there's a clear exit plan.

---

🌾 Midwest (IL, IN, OH, MI, WI, MN, IA, MO, KS, NE)

Major Markets: Chicago, Detroit, Indianapolis, Kansas City, Minneapolis, St. Louis

Characteristics:

Strengths:

• ✅ Manufacturing powerhouse - Automotive, machinery, agriculture equipment
• ✅ Agricultural hub - Grain, livestock, processed foods
• ✅ Central location - Crossroads of America
• ✅ Balanced freight - Strong inbound AND outbound
• ✅ Consistent year-round - Manufacturing operates continuously
• ✅ Major intermodal hubs - Chicago (largest rail hub in U.S.)

Challenges:

• ❌ Winter weather - Snow, ice (Dec-Mar)
• ❌ Competitive rates - High truck supply keeps rates moderate
• ❌ Flat rates - Less volatility than coasts

Rate Dynamics:

The Midwest is the "Balanced Market":

Typical Rates:

• Midwest → Southeast: $1.60–$2.30/mile
• Midwest → Texas: $1.50–$2.20/mile
• Midwest → West Coast: $1.80–$2.50/mile
• Midwest → Northeast: $1.60–$2.40/mile
• Midwest ↔ Midwest: $1.40–$2.00/mile

Why Balanced? The Midwest both produces (manufactured goods, agriculture) and consumes (retail goods, components) in relatively equal measure. Freight flows in multiple directions.

Dispatcher Strategy:

Best Practices:

• ✅ Chicago as major hub - Massive freight availability
• ✅ Automotive corridors - Detroit ↔ Southeast (BMW, Mercedes, VW plants)
• ✅ Agricultural seasons - Harvest time (Aug-Nov) = high demand
• ✅ Accept Midwest loads - Safe, consistent, easy to reload from
• ✅ Avoid deep winter if possible - Weather delays cost money

Peak Seasons:

• Harvest (Aug-Nov): Grain, corn, soybeans to processors
• Q4: Manufacturing output for holiday season
• Spring: Agricultural supplies (seed, fertilizer)

Common Freight:

• Automotive parts and vehicles
• Agricultural products (grain, meat, dairy)
• Manufactured goods (machinery, equipment)
• Retail distribution (consumer goods)
• Food processing (processed meats, packaged foods)

The Bottom Line: The Midwest is the safest market for dispatchers. You can almost always find a load out, rates are predictable, and it's centrally located for accessing all other regions.

---

🦞 New England (MA, CT, RI, VT, NH, ME)

Major Markets: Boston, Hartford, Providence (limited compared to other regions)

Characteristics:

Strengths:

• ✅ Premium rates inbound - Limited truck capacity entering region
• ✅ Seafood exports - Lobster, fish from Maine
• ✅ Manufacturing - Specialized manufacturing, tech
• ✅ Dense population - Retail demand

Challenges:

• ❌ Very weak outbound - Little freight leaving the region
• ❌ Difficult access - Narrow roads, low bridges, restrictive routes
• ❌ Winter weather - Heavy snow, ice (Nov-Mar)
• ❌ Expensive deadhead - Often must leave empty
• ❌ Limited truck parking

Rate Dynamics:

The "Pay to Get In, Deadhead to Get Out" Market:

Inbound (Strong):

• NY → Boston: $2.20–$3.50/mile
• PA → New England: $2.40–$3.80/mile
• Midwest → New England: $2.50–$4.00/mile

Why So High? Many drivers refuse to go to New England because they know they'll deadhead back empty. High rates compensate for the return deadhead.

Outbound (Terrible):

• Boston → NY: $1.00–$1.80/mile (if you can find anything)
• New England → Midwest: $1.20–$2.00/mile (rare)
• New England → anywhere: Often no freight at any price

The Math:

• Inbound load pays $3.00/mile × 200 miles = $600
• Deadhead back 200 miles = $0
• Effective rate: $600 ÷ 400 miles = $1.50/mile actual

Dispatcher Strategy:

Decision Framework:

Only Book New England If:

1. ✅ Inbound rate is $3.00+/mile to compensate for deadhead
2. ✅ Driver is willing to deadhead back to NY/NJ area
3. ✅ It's summer (avoid winter complications)
4. ✅ Delivery is easy access (not downtown Boston)

Avoid New England If:

• ❌ Rate is less than $2.50/mile
• ❌ Winter months (Dec-Feb) - weather risk too high
• ❌ Tight schedule (delays are common)
• ❌ Inexperienced driver (difficult navigation)

Alternative Strategy: Many successful dispatchers completely avoid New England and focus on more balanced markets. The high inbound rates are often offset by deadhead costs and time lost.

Best Practices:

• ✅ Charge premium - $3.00+ minimum per mile
• ✅ Plan deadhead in advance - Know where you're going next
• ✅ NYC as reload point - Deadhead to NY/NJ for next load
• ✅ Summer only - Avoid winter complications
• ✅ Seafood backhaul - Maine lobster to major cities (rare but possible)

Peak Seasons:

• Q4: Holiday retail imports
• Summer: Construction materials, retail goods

Common Freight:

• Inbound: Retail goods, food, construction materials
• Outbound: Seafood (limited), specialized manufacturing (limited)

The Bottom Line: New England is a specialty market. High rates look attractive, but experienced dispatchers calculate the round-trip economics. Unless the inbound rate is exceptional, it's often better to avoid and focus on balanced markets.

---

🌴 Florida - The "Dead Market"

Major Markets: Miami, Jacksonville, Orlando, Tampa

Characteristics:

The Problem: Florida is the #1 worst market in the United States for dispatchers. It's called a "dead market" or "freight graveyard" for good reason.

Why Florida Is Terrible:

Massive Freight Imbalance:

• ❌ High inbound freight - Everyone ships TO Florida (consumer goods)
• ❌ Almost zero outbound - Florida produces very little freight
• ❌ Peninsula geography - Only one way out (north through Georgia)
• ❌ Tourism economy - Services don't generate freight

The Numbers:

• For every 5 trucks entering Florida, only 1-2 have freight leaving
• Result: Oversupply of trucks desperately trying to leave Florida

Rate Dynamics:

Inbound (Moderate to Good):

• TX → FL: $1.80–$2.50/mile
• Midwest → FL: $1.70–$2.40/mile
• Southeast → FL: $1.50–$2.20/mile

Outbound (TERRIBLE):

• FL → TX: $0.80–$1.40/mile (often below operating cost)
• FL → Midwest: $0.90–$1.50/mile
• FL → Southeast: $1.00–$1.60/mile
• FL → anywhere: Often must deadhead at $0/mile

The Calculation:

• Inbound load: $2.00/mile × 900 miles = $1,800
• Outbound load: $1.00/mile × 900 miles = $900 (if you can find one)
• Actual rate: $2,700 ÷ 1,800 miles = $1.50/mile effective

Many carriers lose money on Florida runs because the outbound rate doesn't cover operating costs.

What Florida Produces (Very Little):

Limited Outbound Freight:

• Citrus (oranges, grapefruit) - Seasonal (winter), limited volume
• Tomatoes & vegetables - Some winter produce
• Tropical fruit - Small volume
• Seafood - Very limited

Why So Little?

• Florida's economy is tourism, services, and retirement - none generate freight
• Limited manufacturing
• Limited agriculture (compared to CA or Midwest)
• Imports far exceed exports

Dispatcher Strategy:

Option 1: Avoid Florida Completely (RECOMMENDED) Most experienced dispatchers refuse Florida loads entirely:

• ✅ Focus on balanced markets (Midwest, Southeast)
• ✅ Avoid the headache and financial loss
• ✅ Keep trucks in profitable lanes

Option 2: Charge Premium to Compensate If you MUST go to Florida:

• ✅ Inbound rate minimum: $2.20+/mile
• ✅ Plan for deadhead back to Georgia/Southeast
• ✅ Factor return deadhead into rate negotiation
• ✅ Only in peak season (Q4 holiday) when inbound rates spike

Option 3: Florida Specialists A few carriers specialize in Florida and make it work:

• Build relationships with the few shippers who export (citrus, produce)
• Accept lower margins as business model
• Use Florida as base for consistent inbound freight
• Dedicated routes with regular customers

Best Practices (If You Must Go):

Before Booking:

1. ✅ Inbound rate $2.20+/mile minimum
2. ✅ Calculate round-trip economics
3. ✅ Have exit strategy (know next load source)
4. ✅ Avoid deep South Florida (Miami) - even harder to get out

After Delivery:

1. ✅ Search load boards immediately
2. ✅ Accept Georgia/Southeast reload even at lower rate
3. ✅ Don't wait for "perfect load" - Get out of Florida ASAP
4. ✅ Deadhead to Jacksonville/Georgia if needed (better freight there)

Peak Seasons:

• Q4 (Oct-Dec): Holiday goods - highest inbound rates
• Winter (Jan-Mar): Some citrus/produce outbound
• Spring Break: Tourism supplies

The Bottom Line: Florida is where inexperienced dispatchers lose money and experienced dispatchers fear to tread. The market economics are fundamentally broken due to the inbound/outbound imbalance.

Professional Tip: If a broker offers you a Florida load, your first question should be: "What's the rate AND what's your best outbound load back to Georgia?"

---

Market Comparison Summary

Region	Freight Balance	Rate Level	Difficulty	Dispatcher Rating
West Coast	Strong Outbound	High Out / Low In	Moderate	⭐⭐⭐⭐ Good
East Coast	Balanced	Moderate	Moderate	⭐⭐⭐⭐ Good
Mountain	Very Weak	Low	High	⭐⭐ Avoid
Midwest	Balanced	Moderate	Easy	⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Excellent
New England	Weak Outbound	High In / Low Out	High	⭐⭐ Specialty
Florida	Terrible Outbound	Moderate In / Very Low Out	Very High	⭐ Avoid
Texas	Balanced	Moderate-High	Easy	⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Excellent
Southeast	Strong	Moderate-High	Easy	⭐⭐⭐⭐ Good

---

Strategic Route Planning

Best Freight Triangles (Balanced, Profitable):

Triangle 1: CA → TX → Midwest → CA

• CA → TX: High rate ($2.50+)
• TX → Midwest: Moderate rate ($1.80+)
• Midwest → CA: Moderate rate ($1.80+)
• ✅ Keeps truck moving, all legs profitable

Triangle 2: Midwest → Southeast → Northeast → Midwest

• Midwest → Southeast: Automotive, manufacturing
• Southeast → Northeast: Consumer goods
• Northeast → Midwest: Backhaul moderate rates
• ✅ Consistent freight, balanced markets

Triangle 3: CA → Southeast → TX → CA

• CA → Southeast: High outbound
• Southeast → TX: Manufacturing, automotive
• TX → CA: Backhaul (lower but acceptable)
• ✅ Avoids mountain region

Routes to Avoid:

❌ The Florida Trap:

• Anywhere → FL → (stuck)
• Solution: Just don't go

❌ The Mountain Dead Zone:

• CA → Denver → (stranded)
• Solution: Route around via I-10 (south) or I-80 (north) with confirmed reload

❌ The New England Deadhead:

• Midwest → Boston → deadhead to NY
• Solution: Only if rate is $3.00+ per mile to compensate

---

Seasonal Market Shifts

Q4 (October-December) - Peak Season:

• ✅ Highest rates everywhere (holiday freight)
• ✅ West Coast ports explode with imports
• ✅ Retail distribution to all markets
• ✅ Even Florida becomes somewhat reasonable (still avoid)

Q1 (January-March) - Slow Season:

• ❌ Lowest rates after holiday crash
• ❌ Winter weather disrupts Northeast/Midwest
• ❌ Florida citrus season (one of few times outbound exists)
• Strategy: Accept lower margins to keep trucks moving

Q2 (April-June) - Recovery:

• ✅ Construction season begins (Northeast, Midwest)
• ✅ Agricultural inputs (seed, fertilizer)
• ✅ Flatbed demand increases
• Moderate rates, consistent freight

Q3 (July-September) - Building to Peak:

• ✅ Produce season (CA, PNW)
• ✅ Retail stocking for holiday season begins
• ✅ Reefer demand peaks (summer produce)
• ✅ Back-to-school freight
• Rising rates as Q4 approaches

---

Dispatcher's Market Intelligence Checklist

Before Booking ANY Load:

1. ✅ Know the destination market - Is freight available outbound?
2. ✅ Calculate round-trip economics - Not just one-way rate
3. ✅ Check seasonal factors - Is it peak or slow season?
4. ✅ Consider weather - Will delays impact profitability?
5. ✅ Have exit strategy - How will truck reload?
6. ✅ Compare to alternatives - Is this the best use of truck capacity?

Red Flags - Reject or Negotiate Higher:

• ❌ Florida destination (unless premium inbound rate)
• ❌ Mountain region endpoint without confirmed reload
• ❌ New England in winter
• ❌ Any market where you know outbound is terrible

Green Lights - Safe to Book:

• ✅ Midwest destinations (can reload from anywhere)
• ✅ Texas (balanced market, multiple reload options)
• ✅ Atlanta/Charlotte (Southeast distribution hubs)
• ✅ California outbound (premium rates)

---

Conclusion

Understanding regional market dynamics separates profitable dispatchers from those who struggle. The U.S. freight market is not uniform - each region has unique characteristics, challenges, and opportunities.

Key Takeaways:

Best Markets:

• ✅ Midwest - Balanced, consistent, central location
• ✅ Texas - Strong economy, balanced freight flows
• ✅ California (outbound) - Premium rates leaving the state
• ✅ Southeast - Manufacturing, distribution hubs

Markets Requiring Expertise:

• ⚠️ New England - High inbound rates, plan for deadhead out
• ⚠️ California (inbound) - Lower rates, but necessary to access outbound

Markets to Avoid:

• ❌ Florida - Dead market, freight graveyard
• ❌ Mountain region - Low freight density, harsh conditions

Professional Dispatcher Mindset:

• Always think round-trip, not one-way
• Factor all costs (tolls, fuel, weather delays)
• Build market intelligence through experience
• Know when to say "no" to a load

Success in dispatching comes from knowing not just where freight is, but where it ISN'T.

---

Continue Learning:

• Overview of Truck Dispatching
• Understanding the Trucking Industry
• Truck Types

Master the markets, master dispatching. Understanding regional dynamics is the difference between profit and loss. Continue your education at Carriversity.